Can You Lay Vinyl Flooring Over Vinyl Flooring? A Comprehensive Guide

It’s a question that many homeowners ask: can I lay new vinyl flooring over existing vinyl flooring? After all, it seems like a simple and potentially cost-effective solution. But the reality is, it’s not as straightforward as it might appear. There are definite circumstances where you can lay vinyl over vinyl, and others where it’s a recipe for disaster. Let’s dive into the world of vinyl flooring and explore the ins and outs of laying new vinyl over old.

Image: oldfieldsergio.blogspot.com

Recently, I had a project where I was replacing old, outdated vinyl flooring in my kitchen with a modern, stylish vinyl plank design. I was excited to get started, but I also had a nagging concern: could I simply lay the new vinyl over the old? I wasn’t sure, so I did some research. In the end, I decided to remove the old vinyl as a precaution, but the experience sparked my curiosity about the feasibility of laying vinyl over vinyl in different scenarios.

When Is Laying Vinyl Over Vinyl Acceptable?

Firstly, it’s crucial to understand the complexities involved. There isn’t a universal answer to the question – it depends heavily on the condition of your existing vinyl flooring, the type of new vinyl you’re installing, and the overall structure of your floor.

Here are some scenarios where laying vinyl over vinyl might be acceptable:

• The existing vinyl is in good condition: No cracks, gaps, or loose tiles, and it’s level and smooth.
• The new vinyl is thin and lightweight: This reduces the risk of unevenness and buckling.
• The subfloor is structurally sound: Ensuring that the underlying subfloor is strong and stable will prevent future problems.

Factors To Consider Before Laying Vinyl Over Vinyl

Now, let’s explore the potential pitfalls you need to be aware of. Not every vinyl installation over vinyl will be successful. Before you start, consider these factors:

1. Condition of the Existing Vinyl Floor

This is arguably the most crucial factor. If your existing vinyl is in poor condition – damaged, cracked, or uneven – it’s highly recommended to remove it. Laying new flooring over a compromised base will inevitably lead to problems, such as unevenness, buckling, or even cracking.

It’s also important to consider the age of the existing vinyl. If it’s old and brittle, it’s more likely to crack or break when walked on, making it unsuitable for layering.

Image: viewfloor.co

2. Type of New Vinyl Flooring

Not all vinyl flooring is created equal. Certain types, like luxury vinyl planks (LVP), are thicker and heavier than others. Using heavier vinyl on top of existing vinyl can put undue stress on the subfloor, leading to problems like unevenness, buckling, or even structural issues.

3. Thickness of the Existing Vinyl

Combining multiple layers of vinyl flooring can significantly increase the overall height of your floor. This can cause problems with doors opening and closing properly or even affect the functionality of appliances like dishwashers or refrigerators.

4. Subfloor Inspection

Before even considering laying vinyl over vinyl, it’s imperative to thoroughly inspect your subfloor. Ensure it’s structurally sound, level, and dry. Any problems with the subfloor will be magnified by layering vinyl on top, potentially leading to catastrophic failures down the line.

A professional inspection can help you identify potential issues, but if you are attempting this on your own, it’s best to err on the side of caution. It’s much easier to remove existing vinyl than to deal with problems later.

Alternatives to Laying Vinyl over Vinyl: When to Remove the Old Flooring

If the existing vinyl flooring isn’t in good condition, or if you’re concerned about potential complications, removing the existing flooring is generally the best course of action. This may seem like an extra step, but it can prevent headaches in the long run. Removing old vinyl flooring can be a relatively straightforward DIY project but requires proper tools and techniques.

Here are some of the benefits of removing existing vinyl flooring:

• Creates a completely level and smooth surface for the new flooring.
• Allows for a thorough inspection of the subfloor to identify and address any potential issues.
• Eliminates the risk of unevenness, buckling, or cracking in the new flooring.
• Ensures you have the desired floor height.

Tips and Expert Advice for Laying Vinyl Over Vinyl

If you are determined to lay new vinyl over existing flooring, it’s crucial to follow these expert tips carefully:

1. Thoroughly assess the existing floor: Look for signs of damage, cracks, gaps, or unevenness. If you find any, consider removing the existing floor.
2. Choose thin, lightweight vinyl flooring: This allows for minimal stress on the subfloor.
3. Use a leveling compound if needed: This can help to create a smooth, level surface for your new flooring.
4. Use a moisture barrier: This helps to protect your new flooring from moisture damage.
5. Install a good quality underlayment: This provides cushioning and helps to prevent noise transmission.
6. Consider professional installation: If you’re unsure about any aspect of the process, consult with a flooring professional. This can help to ensure that the new flooring is installed properly and last for years to come.

Even if you are confident in your DIY skills, remember that every project has its nuances. Laying vinyl over vinyl is not a standard practice for good reason. It introduces an added layer of complexity that can be best avoided. Unless you are completely comfortable with the potential risks and challenges, removing the old flooring is usually the safest and most reliable approach for achieving a beautiful, long-lasting flooring installation.

FAQ: Laying Vinyl Over Vinyl

Q: Is it okay to lay vinyl sheet goods over existing vinyl?

A: The general rule is to avoid laying vinyl sheet goods over existing vinyl. Sheet goods are typically heavier and less forgiving than other vinyl types, increasing the chance of unevenness and buckling.

Q: What if my existing vinyl is glued down?

A: If the existing vinyl is glued down, it is highly recommended to remove it before installing your new flooring.

Q: What if my subfloor is a bit uneven?

A: If you have minor unevenness, you can use a leveling compound to even out the surface. However, larger imperfections may require more extensive repairs or removal of the existing flooring.

Q: Can I use underlayment when laying vinyl over vinyl?

A: It’s a good idea to use underlayment, even when laying vinyl over vinyl. It helps to absorb sound, cushion the floor, and provide additional support. However, choose a thin underlayment to avoid adding too much height to your floor.

Q: What about luxury vinyl planks (LVP)?

A: Laying LVP over existing vinyl is generally not recommended, as LVP is typically heavier and can create more stress on the subfloor.

Can You Lay Vinyl Flooring Over Vinyl Flooring

Conclusion

Laying vinyl flooring over existing vinyl flooring is a complex topic. It requires a thorough assessment of your existing floor, subfloor, and the type of vinyl you are using. If you’re unsure, it’s always best to err on the side of caution and remove the existing flooring. However, with careful planning, preparation, and attention to detail, it may be possible to lay new vinyl over existing vinyl successfully. Just remember to weigh the risks and benefits before making your final decision.

Are you considering laying vinyl flooring over existing vinyl? What are your concerns or questions? We’d love to hear from you in the comments! Share your thoughts and experiences.